Dispute Resolution

Arbitration vs Litigation in India: Which Dispute Resolution to Choose?

February 12, 2026 • 9 min read

Your contract has a dispute resolution clause. Do you even know what it says? Most businesses sign contracts without thinking about what happens when things go wrong. But the choice between arbitration and litigation can mean the difference between resolving a dispute in 6 months or 6 years.

India's courts handle over 5 crore pending cases. The average commercial dispute takes 3-5 years to resolve through litigation. Arbitration, done right, can cut that to 6-12 months. But it's not always the better choice. Here's how to decide.

What is Arbitration?

Arbitration is a private dispute resolution mechanism where parties agree to have their dispute decided by one or more impartial arbitrators instead of going to court. The process is governed by the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996 (amended in 2015, 2019, and 2021).

The arbitrator(s) hear both sides, examine evidence, and deliver an arbitral award that is legally binding and enforceable like a court decree.

What is Litigation?

Litigation is the traditional court-based dispute resolution process. One party files a suit in the appropriate civil court, and the matter proceeds through pleadings, evidence, arguments, and judgment, all within the public court system.

Head-to-Head Comparison

⏱️ Speed

Arbitration: 6-18 months typically. The 2015 amendment mandates completion within 12 months (extendable by 6 months by parties). Litigation: 3-10+ years for commercial disputes. Appeals can add 2-5 more years.

💰 Cost

Arbitration: Higher upfront costs (arbitrator fees, institutional charges), but lower overall cost due to speed. Litigation: Lower filing fees, but lawyer costs accumulate over years. Total cost often exceeds arbitration.

🔒 Confidentiality

Arbitration: Proceedings are private and confidential. No public record. Litigation: Court proceedings are public. Judgment is part of public record.

📋 Flexibility

Arbitration: Parties can choose the arbitrator, venue, language, and procedural rules. Litigation: Rigid procedural rules (CPC, Evidence Act). Court assigns the judge.

🔄 Appeal

Arbitration: Very limited grounds for challenge (Section 34). No appeal on merits. Litigation: Multiple levels of appeal (District → High Court → Supreme Court).

🌍 Cross-Border Enforcement

Arbitration: Enforceable in 170+ countries under the New York Convention. Litigation: Indian court judgments have very limited enforceability abroad.

When to Choose Arbitration

✅ High-value commercial disputes (₹1 crore+) where speed matters
✅ International contracts where cross-border enforcement is needed
✅ Confidential matters (trade secrets, proprietary technology)
✅ Technical disputes requiring industry-specific expertise
✅ Ongoing business relationships where preserving the relationship matters
✅ B2B contracts between sophisticated parties

When to Choose Litigation

✅ Low-value disputes where arbitrator fees would be disproportionate
✅ Disputes requiring injunctive relief (court orders to stop something)
✅ Third-party involvement (arbitration only binds parties to the agreement)
✅ Consumer disputes (consumer forums are faster and cheaper)
✅ Disputes involving fraud or criminal elements
✅ Cases where you want to set legal precedent

The Mediation Act 2023: A Third Option

India's new Mediation Act 2023 introduces institutionalized mediation as a formal dispute resolution mechanism. Unlike arbitration (where the arbitrator decides) or litigation (where the judge decides), mediation involves a neutral mediator who helps parties reach their own settlement.

Key advantages of mediation:

Fastest resolution (days to weeks, not months)
Cheapest option (no prolonged proceedings)
Preserves relationships (collaborative, not adversarial)
Mediated settlement agreements are enforceable under the Act

How to Draft a Strong Dispute Resolution Clause

A well-drafted dispute resolution clause should include:

Step 1: Negotiation: "The parties shall first attempt to resolve the dispute through good-faith negotiations within 30 days."
Step 2: Mediation: "If negotiations fail, the parties shall attempt mediation under the Mediation Act 2023 within 60 days."
Step 3: Arbitration/Litigation: "If mediation fails, the dispute shall be referred to arbitration under the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996, with [number] arbitrator(s), seated in [city]."

Pro tip: Always specify the seat (legal place) of arbitration, the number of arbitrators (1 for disputes under ₹1 crore, 3 for higher), and the governing law plainly.

Don't Sign Blindly.

Templates are just a start. Use AI to scan your specific contract for hidden risks and unfair clauses in 60 seconds.

Analyze Your Contract Free →

Key Takeaways

✅ Arbitration is faster, private, and internationally enforceable
✅ Litigation is better for low-value disputes, injunctions, and fraud cases
✅ Mediation (under the 2023 Act) is the fastest and cheapest option
✅ A tiered clause (negotiation → mediation → arbitration) is ideal
✅ Always specify seat, number of arbitrators, and governing law
❌ Never leave the dispute resolution clause blank or vague

The best time to think about disputes is before they happen. A well-drafted dispute resolution clause is not legal boilerplate. It's strategic insurance that determines how quickly and cheaply you can resolve problems when they arise.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is arbitration better than litigation in India?

For most commercial disputes, yes. Arbitration is typically faster (6-18 months vs 3-15 years for litigation), confidential, and allows parties to choose expert arbitrators. However, litigation may be better for cases requiring injunctions, class actions, or matters of public interest.

How much does arbitration cost in India?

Arbitration costs include arbitrator fees (Rs 50,000 to Rs 5 lakhs+ per hearing depending on the claim value and arbitrator's seniority), institutional fees if using bodies like SIAC or MCIA, and lawyer fees. For disputes above Rs 1 crore, arbitration is generally cheaper than litigation due to faster resolution.

Is an arbitration clause mandatory in contracts?

No, but it is strongly recommended for commercial contracts. Without an arbitration clause, disputes default to litigation in civil courts. The clause must be in writing as per Section 7 of the Arbitration and Conciliation Act 1996.

Can an arbitration award be challenged in court?

Yes, but on very limited grounds under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act. Grounds include incapacity of a party, invalid arbitration agreement, improper notice, the award dealing with matters beyond the scope of arbitration, or the award being in conflict with Indian public policy.